Re: Google's Scholarly Search Service and Institutional OA Self-Archiving

From: Stevan Harnad <>
Date: Fri, 19 Nov 2004 03:51:09 +0000

On Thu, 18 Nov 2004, Leslie Carr wrote:

> Google's new... http:/// [delivers]... a search
> service... [that is selective for] scholarly and scientific resources...
> from all web sites... across the complete spectrum of scholarly enquiry...
> [plus] a basic level of citation analysis..

    An extremely valuable and welcome new service (and about time!):

    "Re: proposed collaboration: google + open citation linking" (2001)

> [But] Google is not offering increased Open Access, just improved resource
> discovery of current ad-hoc OA. To advance we still need to offer carrot
> and stick, policies and mandates...
> [The] Google scholarly search engine is a welcome addition to
> the arsenal of services that researchers use to mine the literature -
> but it is still OA Institutional Repositories that provide the best
> chance of getting readable copies of those papers into Google!

In other words, please don't imagine that Google will now provide OA
full-texts for you! Google is now selectively gathering and making them
visible, and even providing some citation impact counts -- but it can
only do that with those full-texts that have been made OA by putting
them on the Web!

Our estimates across disciplines indicate that currently at most only 20%
of the journal articles being published today are being made OA:

This wonderful new service from google should (as Les Carr indicates) be taken
as yet another strong incentive for authors' institutions and research funders
to mandate and reward OA -- and authors to do -- self-archiving of the
remaining 80%!

    "What Provosts Need to Mandate" (2003)

    "University policy mandating self-archiving of research output" (2004)

    "Mandating OA around the corner?"

    "Guide for the Perplexed: Re: UK Select Committee Inquiry"

    "Critique of PSP/AAP Critique of NIH Proposal"

    "Critique of STM Critique of NIH Proposal"

Stevan Harnad

Relevant Prior Amsci Forum Topic Threads:

    "Citation-Linking" (1999)

    "Economic effects of link-based search engines on e-journals" (2000)

    "A Search Engine for Searching Across Distributed Eprint Archives"

    "Testing the citation-ranking search engine: Citebase" (2002)

    "Scientometric OAI Search Engines"

    "Need for systematic scientometric analyses of open-access data"

    "How to compare research impact of toll- vs. open-access research" (2003)

    "Measuring cumulating research impact loss across fields and time"

    "Do Open-Access Articles Have a Greater Research Impact?"

    "Early Download Impact Predicts Later Citation Impact"

    "Self-Archiving Incentives: Download Impact Counts"
Received on Fri Nov 19 2004 - 03:51:09 GMT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.0 : Fri Dec 10 2010 - 19:47:41 GMT