Project overview
This project explores philosophical questions related to pregnancy, birth, parenthood and gender - and seeks to use philosophy to improve the wellbeing of parents and people who are pregnant or giving birth. The project is led by Fiona Woollard (Southampton) and Elselijn Kingma (formerly of Southampton now Sowerby Professor in Philosophy and Medicine at King's College London).
The questions we explore include:
- Is the fetus part of the maternal organism?
- How do central moral notions, such as doing harm, apply to pregnancy and early parenthood?
-Does the radically transformative character of pregnancy mean that those who have never been pregnant are excluded from certain kinds of knowledge about pregnancy and its consequences?
- How do unhelpful ideals of motherhood influence the way we think about, and treat, pregnant people and parents?
- What makes a parent count as a mother?
-How can we stop parental duties becoming overdemanding?
Our research has had considerable impact outside academia. It has been used to:
- Shape the Dutch legal, medical, activist and policy framework surrounding maternity care for those birthing 'outside the guidelines', defending the right of those giving birth to make autonomous decisions.
- Develop policy and resources to enable healthcare professionals to provide non-judgemental infant feeding support.
- Inform policy on alcohol use in pregnancy.
- Train healthcare professionals in gender-inclusive language and practice in perinatal care.
- Develop maternity mentoring material and improve policy and practice surrounding parental leave.
We produced two 4* Impact Case Studies for REF 2021, and are developing new case studies for the next REF.
The project began with "Taking Pregnancy Seriously in Metaphysics, Ethics and Epistemology", a series of workshops held between June 2014 and September 2015 and funded by a University of Southampton “Adventures in Research” Grant, with additional support from the Southampton Ethics Centre, the British Society for Philosophy of Science and the Aristotelian Society.
Since then....
Professor Kingma was awarded a €1.2m ERC Starting Grant for the Better Understanding the Metaphysics of Pregnancy (BUMP) Project. As part of this project, we were joined by Research Fellows, Drs Alexander Geddes, Suki Finn, Jonathan Grosse, and Anne-Sophie Meincke, and PhD students, Teresa Baron, Sigmund (Ziggy) Schilpzand, and Alexander Mortensen.
The Philosophy of Pregnancy, Birth and Early Motherhood project at Southampton was Highly Commended for the Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences Research Project of the Year at the Times Higher Education Awards, 2018.
Professor Woollard held a Non-Residential Fellowship in Philosophy of Transformative Experience at the Experience Project (Templeton Foundation, University of Notre Dame, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill) (September 2016-February 2017) exploring pregnancy as an epistemically transformative experience. The resulting paper “Mother Knows Best: Pregnancy, Applied Ethics, and Epistemically Transformative Experiences”, was awarded the Journal of Applied Philosophy Annual Prize 2021 (£1000) for the best paper published in the journal in 2021.
Kingma and Woollard's paper “Can You Do Harm to Your Fetus? Pregnancy, Barriers, and the Doing/Allowing Distinction" was selected for the 2025 Philosophers Annual. The Philosophers Annual attempts to identify the ten best articles published in Philosophy each year.
The questions we explore include:
- Is the fetus part of the maternal organism?
- How do central moral notions, such as doing harm, apply to pregnancy and early parenthood?
-Does the radically transformative character of pregnancy mean that those who have never been pregnant are excluded from certain kinds of knowledge about pregnancy and its consequences?
- How do unhelpful ideals of motherhood influence the way we think about, and treat, pregnant people and parents?
- What makes a parent count as a mother?
-How can we stop parental duties becoming overdemanding?
Our research has had considerable impact outside academia. It has been used to:
- Shape the Dutch legal, medical, activist and policy framework surrounding maternity care for those birthing 'outside the guidelines', defending the right of those giving birth to make autonomous decisions.
- Develop policy and resources to enable healthcare professionals to provide non-judgemental infant feeding support.
- Inform policy on alcohol use in pregnancy.
- Train healthcare professionals in gender-inclusive language and practice in perinatal care.
- Develop maternity mentoring material and improve policy and practice surrounding parental leave.
We produced two 4* Impact Case Studies for REF 2021, and are developing new case studies for the next REF.
The project began with "Taking Pregnancy Seriously in Metaphysics, Ethics and Epistemology", a series of workshops held between June 2014 and September 2015 and funded by a University of Southampton “Adventures in Research” Grant, with additional support from the Southampton Ethics Centre, the British Society for Philosophy of Science and the Aristotelian Society.
Since then....
Professor Kingma was awarded a €1.2m ERC Starting Grant for the Better Understanding the Metaphysics of Pregnancy (BUMP) Project. As part of this project, we were joined by Research Fellows, Drs Alexander Geddes, Suki Finn, Jonathan Grosse, and Anne-Sophie Meincke, and PhD students, Teresa Baron, Sigmund (Ziggy) Schilpzand, and Alexander Mortensen.
The Philosophy of Pregnancy, Birth and Early Motherhood project at Southampton was Highly Commended for the Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences Research Project of the Year at the Times Higher Education Awards, 2018.
Professor Woollard held a Non-Residential Fellowship in Philosophy of Transformative Experience at the Experience Project (Templeton Foundation, University of Notre Dame, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill) (September 2016-February 2017) exploring pregnancy as an epistemically transformative experience. The resulting paper “Mother Knows Best: Pregnancy, Applied Ethics, and Epistemically Transformative Experiences”, was awarded the Journal of Applied Philosophy Annual Prize 2021 (£1000) for the best paper published in the journal in 2021.
Kingma and Woollard's paper “Can You Do Harm to Your Fetus? Pregnancy, Barriers, and the Doing/Allowing Distinction" was selected for the 2025 Philosophers Annual. The Philosophers Annual attempts to identify the ten best articles published in Philosophy each year.
Staff
Lead researchers
Research outputs
2020, Moral Philosophy and Politics, 7(2), 239-254
Type: article
Fiona Woollard,
2019, International Breastfeeding Journal, 14
Type: article